First Time Is A Charm

On her first try, Carling Coffing wins the Women’s Metropolitan Amateur Championship

By Ed Letsinger

Most people heading out for vacation would be home packing and taking care of last minute details but Carling Coffing got ready for her trip by taking care of business out on the golf course.

Playing in the 91st annual Women’s Metropolitan Amateur Championship for the first time ever, the 20-year-old Ohio State University junior defeated Kim Keyer-Scott, 2 and 1 in the championship flight finals at Summit Hills Country Club in Crestview Hills, Ky.

“We’re leaving on a cruise tomorrow and now I can just relax and hang out in my bathing suit with my new Met trophy,” said a smiling Coffing afterwards.

Coffing, who had a successful high school career at Middletown High School that included a state title her sophomore year, has been a mainstay on the tournament circuit for the past several years but had never made a Met appearance primarily because of scheduling conflicts.

“As a junior (golfer) there are so many tournaments to choose from, and for a while there I was just concentrating on playing in ones where I knew college coaches would be,” she explains.

All that exposure eventually landed her at OSU, where this year she finished second at the Big Ten Championship.

Coffing’s week started out strong on Monday during the 18-hole qualifier where she fired a 2-over-par 73 to share medalist honors with Keyer-Scott to earn a No. 2 seed.  In the opening round of match play, she defeated Laura Schild 6 and 5 before getting a scare in the quarterfinals against University of Cincinnati’s Allison Mayborg.  Two down at the turn, Coffing grinded out a 1-up win before coming back strong against Lynn Thompson in the semifinals with a convincing 6 and 4 victory to earn a spot in the championship match against Keyer-Scott.

Keyer-Scott, the top seed and former Northern Kentucky University All-American whose name has frequented the top of the leader board at many local tournaments for several years running, is still in pursuit of her first Met title after advancing to the title match for the second time in the past three years.

“I want to win every tournament I play in,” said Keyer-Scott, when asked if the elusive Met title bothers her.  “I just didn’t play well today.  My swing was a little loose and golf was work for me today and that’s not usually the way it is.”

After a back-and-forth front side by both players marred by a few shaky shots and a good dose of scrambling, Coffing made the turn 2-up and after losing a hole on the par-3 tenth, appeared to take control of the match by winning holes 11, 12 and 13 to go 4-up.  A steady par at 11 with Keyer-Scott scrambling and conceding the hole was followed by another tenuous par at No. 12.  After sticking her second shot to about 25 feet on the 391-yard par-5, a tough pin position on an uphill slop led to a shaky three-putt as Coffing’s ball twice rolled back below the hole.  But Keyer-Scott had found the water on her second shot and missed her chance at par with an approach that left her with a tough putt.  Another par at 13 had Coffing thinking the end was near.

“I think I got a little over-confident at that point and started thinking about when we were going to be done rather than focusing on golf…but she also made some good shots.”

Keyer-Scott, who admitted that her chances of winning at that point were slim – “I was thinking more about a respectable score” – hung in and gained momentum back by rolling in about a 25-foot clutch birdie putt on 14 and got another hole back with a solid par on 16 to cut Coffing’s lead to 2-up.

Both were on the green in two on 17 but Coffing, who was facing a long, tough uphill putt, sailed her ball well past the hole but luckily it rolled back to about three feet.  Stepping back three times before lining up over the ball, she drained a slippery, 3-foot knee-knocker to win the title.

“I was just a little bit too excited when I hit that (first) putt and I didn’t think it would roll back that much,” said Coffing.  “I guess the golf Gods were with me on that hole.”

It was a good week for Coffing, who had her Mom, Leona, on the bag all week.  She attributed most of her success to a solid short game and the win should help down the road when college golf season begins.

“It’s always nice to win a tournament and honestly, it’s been a while since I have won one,” said Coffing.  “This will give me a little confidence and now I just want to work on my game to get prepared for OSU.”